In a mixed-use building, which of the following elements violates the 2010 ADA Standards for communication features?
QUESTION ANALYSIS:
I. JURISDICTION: I. JURISDICTION: Under 2010 ADA Standards Section 217 and Section 308, public pay phones must have operable parts within reach ranges. For a forward or side reach, the highest operable part must be no higher than 48 inches (ADA 308.2.1, 308.3.1). Option A has the highest operable part at 54 inches, exceeding the maximum. Options B, C, and D relate to counters and tables, not communication features. Therefore, A is the violation.
II. SCOPING: ADA Standards Sections 217 and 308 scope reach-range requirements for operable parts of communication features such as public pay phones, requiring compliance with the applicable forward or side reach maximum height.
III. CONFLICT RESOLUTION: No conflicting standard applies; the 2010 ADA Standards reach-range requirements for communication features are the controlling technical criteria for public pay phone operable part height.
IV. CODE VALUES — VERBATIM: Sections 308.2.1 and 308.3.1 establish a maximum reach height of 48 inches for the highest operable part of an element requiring a forward or side reach, such as a public pay phone.
V. DISTRACTORS: Options B, C, and D describe counters, desks, and tables, which are governed by different reach and clearance provisions and are not communication features, so they do not violate Section 217 or 308. Therefore, option A is correct.